I never even noticed this thread before... I think it's a little nuts going through all kinds of unqualified opinions (liking a gun isn't enough to make it good) to pull out the few that are really worthwhile (and actually based on real technical knowledge).

I like Droc's giant pro con list on page 1... for the TMs it's pretty accurate actually. With the store I'm starting to answer alot of these basic questions over and over... maybe it's time to compile a nice clean pro con list for as many models as possible...

Remember that the original request was to comment on guns you actually own. Not unqualified opinions. It was also geared towards finding a 'best' model.

As such, this thread has worked well.

A complete Pro/Con list for each model would be great, but would take lots of time. For consistency, it has to be done by no more than two people who will coordinate and would really KNOW what they are talking about. That's hard to find.

well you could always ask for people who on the guns and ask what they think are pros and cons and just take the ones that popped up the most.

like in my case the SG1
pro
large battery
good platform for snipers, SAW's and assults rifles
long inner barrel
bi-pod

con
crecky plastic
its to long for CQB (still use it anyway)
V2 mech box
metal bodies are hard to come by
bi-pod is not that good

JOC has something like that, the Airsoft database http://www.jocairsoft.com/forums/airsoftdb.php

A question what would be a better choice?
AK-74M or a MP5 SD 5 or 6 i cant choose and its driving me insane!

Did you read this thread at all? If you dont OWN either, this is not the place to ask.
But if you READ the thread, you will be able to get a better idea.

Before you think about buying, how about you get age-verified?