Airsoft Canada

Airsoft Canada (https://airsoftcanada.com/forums.php)
-   Airsoft Guns Discussion (https://airsoftcanada.com/forumdisplay.php?f=53)
-   -   bar-10 with tk twist? (https://airsoftcanada.com/showthread.php?t=101056)

krap101 March 26th, 2010 04:21

bar-10 with tk twist?
 
So, if I want to get a twist barrel for my bar-10g, I'd want a 430mm barrel (they don't make the 303, so supposedly the 430 goes a little into the suppressor) downgrade to a 100sp spring, probably get a better bucking and do the teflon mods etc? How would this compare to the 500fps setup?

Styrak March 26th, 2010 04:27

That type of barrel's main performance characteristic degrades when going above 330fps.

krap101 March 26th, 2010 04:30

I meant a 500fps setup like laylax edgi modded the heck out. I know it won't be the same, but I'm guessing that it'd be reasonably close except the fps. Maybe 70-80%? The 100sp is 330fps with .2's

CDN_Stalker March 26th, 2010 07:36

Wasn't aware they made a 100SP spring for bolt action rifles.

krap101 March 26th, 2010 13:48

http://www.airsoftgi.com/product_inf...oducts_id=4946

:)

Amos March 26th, 2010 14:04

It'll go far... but good luck having people feel the hits at that distance.

Azathoth March 26th, 2010 16:49

the TK barrel is no worse than your typical 6.03 tightbore at velocities >400 FPS. But why would you spend nearly double the money for the TK twist when you can get EDGI barrels that work regardless of velocity

krap101 March 26th, 2010 17:13

Because, from what I understand, to get comparable performance, you'd need to spend alot more.. The tk barrel for a bar-10 is like 55$, and 16$ for a lower spring. To get comparable accuracy/range, (I'm guessing) you'd need to spend 300+.

Anyways, edgi barrels are like 60$ here.

Donster March 26th, 2010 17:22

honestly i dont see the point. If you upgrade your gun to shoot at higher velocities with a good tightbore, you will get farther range with it than with the TK Twist.

The twist only add additional accuracy (to an extent). If the two barrels are comparable in accuracy, why not upgrade the power of your gun and get the added bonus of more range?

Sniper's are about both range AND accuracy. The TK Twist only gives you one.

Thenooblord March 26th, 2010 17:28

Quote:

Originally Posted by Donster (Post 1196014)
honestly i dont see the point. If you upgrade your gun to shoot at higher velocities with a good tightbore, you will get farther range with it than with the TK Twist.

The twist only add additional accuracy (to an extent). If the two barrels are comparable in accuracy, why not upgrade the power of your gun and get the added bonus of more range?

Sniper's are about both range AND accuracy. The TK Twist only gives you one.

I beg to differ, my Masada shoots about 310 has a TK twist and a V notch hopup rubber and its shoots farther than my 390 FPS AKs 74U

Amos March 26th, 2010 17:44

Quote:

Originally Posted by Thenooblord (Post 1196018)
I beg to differ, my Masada shoots about 310 has a TK twist and a V notch hopup rubber and its shoots farther than my 390 FPS AKs 74U

Things with a BASR don't work exactly like they do with an AEG...

The extra FPS in the sniper rifle is so that people FEEL their single hit over distance rather than multiple small hits.

I've gone a season using a 310 FPS VSR-10... I had ALOT of hits that people simply didn't feel.. and it gets VERY frustrating.

Donster March 26th, 2010 17:53

Quote:

Originally Posted by Thenooblord (Post 1196018)
I beg to differ, my Masada shoots about 310 has a TK twist and a V notch hopup rubber and its shoots farther than my 390 FPS AKs 74U

doesn't the masada have a longer inner barrel than the 74u?

also, does the 74u have the vnotch rubber?

CDN_Stalker March 26th, 2010 18:35

Quote:

Originally Posted by krap101 (Post 1195868)

Odd.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Amos (Post 1195884)
It'll go far... but good luck having people feel the hits at that distance.

If he uses 0.30g BBs, there wil be a decent chance anyone within 200ft will feel it.

Donster March 26th, 2010 18:38

Quote:

Originally Posted by CDN_Stalker (Post 1196063)
If he uses 0.30g BBs, there wil be a decent chance anyone within 200ft will feel it.

but if he uses a TK twist and 330fps spring, will he even be able to accurately put BBs out to that range?

Amos March 26th, 2010 19:17

Quote:

Originally Posted by CDN_Stalker (Post 1196063)
Odd.



If he uses 0.30g BBs, there wil be a decent chance anyone within 200ft will feel it.

... Firing a BB at someone over a long distance with it traveling at 250~ FPS at the muzzle?

I don't know about your targets... but the people I shoot at would be able to move out of the way of that.

krap101 March 26th, 2010 19:41

I know black bb's generally are worse quality than the white ones (I have no idea why) but if you used black bb's, you wouldn't be able to see them flying, so people won't try to dodge as much. I know I won't be able to lead someone enough to hit them running horizontally, but you should still be able to hit them if they are coming towards or going away from you right? 250' with 330fps, so lets say 250 average velocity (total guess right now) so that's about a second, which isn't terrible.

Has anybody ever thought of getting a laser range finder, and getting a metronome? If you do your range/average muzzle velocity, you get a time value. Once you have the "rhythm" in your head, you can estimate alot better where they'll be in the 1 or 1.1 seconds or whatever. (assuming they're moving at constant velocity no wind etc)

Styrak March 26th, 2010 20:53

You're forgetting that BB's start slowing down as soon as they leave the barrel.

CDN_Stalker March 26th, 2010 20:58

Quote:

Originally Posted by Donster (Post 1196066)
but if he uses a TK twist and 330fps spring, will he even be able to accurately put BBs out to that range?

If I can get 0.30g BBs out to 300ft easily (looked like they were floating out there and maybe a 20ft grouping, but still made it to that distance high enough to hit a standing person) when my M24 was shooting 340fps one time for a CQB game with 0.20g BBs........... why wouldn't they? All ends up being hop up adjustment. Heavy BB and hop up trumps velocity every time for range.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Amos (Post 1196097)
... Firing a BB at someone over a long distance with it traveling at 250~ FPS at the muzzle?

I don't know about your targets... but the people I shoot at would be able to move out of the way of that.

Then wait until they stop staring at you before you fire. Sheesh! Lol ;)

You know I've been running my M24 the past year at just under 400fps (loving it) and have been using 0.36g Bs, right? And 200ft is easy for me, and past if I need to. Of all around here I'd expect you minimum to have paid attention to my raving about that velocity and ammo, even if it only comes out my barrel at 300fps.

CDN_Stalker March 26th, 2010 21:06

Quote:

Originally Posted by krap101 (Post 1196112)
I know black bb's generally are worse quality than the white ones (I have no idea why) but if you used black bb's, you wouldn't be able to see them flying, so people won't try to dodge as much. I know I won't be able to lead someone enough to hit them running horizontally, but you should still be able to hit them if they are coming towards or going away from you right? 250' with 330fps, so lets say 250 average velocity (total guess right now) so that's about a second, which isn't terrible.

Has anybody ever thought of getting a laser range finder, and getting a metronome? If you do your range/average muzzle velocity, you get a time value. Once you have the "rhythm" in your head, you can estimate alot better where they'll be in the 1 or 1.1 seconds or whatever. (assuming they're moving at constant velocity no wind etc)

That's about as lame as a guy using a calculator to set his scope vs. distance to................. works for real steel, for airsoft it's non-existant and one would have to be a mathmatical genius to create a working formula, only to find out it won't work either because of the variability of air currrents between the shooter and the target.

krap101 March 26th, 2010 21:27

Well, the formula only has to be as accurate as the bb, so not very. Maybe find the distance where the velocity of the bb is mostly linear (it should be an exponential function), so I wanna guess maybe 50-100 ft before the velocity curve levels off. I don't know...

For the bb's slowing down, I guessed it'd end up with 250 fps when it hits, which I guess is a little high. Maybe it'd be closer to 50? So maybe 3-5 seconds.. which is worse ><

CDN_Stalker March 27th, 2010 09:00

He claims to be able to use it out to 300ft. Knowing the way BBs fly and how unpredictable they are past 200ft, I really can't see how he uses the mildot and calculator to sort out how many clicks to set his scope, or to hold off. Me, past 150ft, I just send a tracing round out first, then go for holdoff. Much simpler and faster. Lol

krap101 March 27th, 2010 16:55

So, from your experience, would you rather have a tightbore and 500fps or a twist with 340 fps? (I know you said hopup+heavy>velocity, but I'm trying to decide) Heavy bb+low velocity=even less range, even with hopup? Or when you shoot the bb do you aim low so the bb will swoop up?

FOX_111 March 27th, 2010 16:59

I made the formula and ballistic table for various BB weights and fps. It work, but like Stalker said, it's as acurate as the BBs is. Wich translade to an educated guess on where to put your hold over or hold under at a set range.

And for the record, I'm far from a mathematical genious. I just used the data compiled by CyberSloth from the airsoft trajectory project and came up with a little formula that take the mildot ranging formula into account.

Since mildot ranging under 500fps is kinda sketchy, this also translate into the innacuracy of the shots.

krap101 March 27th, 2010 17:01

Quote:

Originally Posted by CDN_Stalker (Post 1196198)
That's about as lame as a guy using a calculator to set his scope vs. distance to................. works for real steel, for airsoft it's non-existant and one would have to be a mathmatical genius to create a working formula, only to find out it won't work either because of the variability of air currrents between the shooter and the target.

I know that some people spend a bunch of money on airsoft, so I'm wondering if someone would buy a real intervention, and tweak the program for the wind speed air pressure etc... lol.

CDN_Stalker March 27th, 2010 17:13

Quote:

Originally Posted by FOX_111 (Post 1196683)
I made the formula and ballistic table for various BB weights and fps. It work, but like Stalker said, it's as acurate as the BBs is. Wich translade to an educated guess on where to put your hold over or hold under at a set range.

And for the record, I'm far from a mathematical genious. I just used the data compiled by CyberSloth from the airsoft trajectory project and came up with a little formula that take the mildot ranging formula into account.

Since mildot ranging under 500fps is kinda sketchy, this also translate into the innacuracy of the shots.

Ah, ok. I still prefer the test shot. :P


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 14:08.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.