Need help deciding on a primary weapon
 

Hey guys, as the title says, I am a beginner airsofter, I have been following the sport for a a few years and have done some research so i know most of the basics, but due to financial reasons i was never able to actually get in and play
Since I am starting, I would like a reliable platform that will last me a long time. And no doubt i will be upgrading it whenever i can in the future (starting with tightbore and hop-up to make those China-clones super accurate).

These are the options I am considering (in no particular order):
G36:
JG MK36K - http://www.airsoftgi.com/product_inf...oducts_id=4219
I know the TSD/SRC G36K has vastly superior externals (with fibreglass-reinforced nylon, as opposed to the molded ABS on the JG), but I have seen some owner responses, including one here on ASC, that have stated there can be serious quality control issues that affect the basic function of the gun. also, its internals are proprietary and not compatible with aftermarket standard parts, which is unacceptable by me, as I will need to upgrade.

AK74M:
CYMA CM047C - http://www.airsoftgi.com/product_inf...oducts_id=4006
OR
CYMA CM040C - http://www.airsoftgi.com/product_inf...oducts_id=4737
Both these guns are full metal. From what i understand, the first one, the CM047C is the OLDER version, with all metal parts being pot metal/alloy, and uses Ver. 3 Tokyo Marui compatible internals. Whereas the CM040C is newer, has a STEEL receiver and dust cover, with all other metal parts being pot alloy, and uses Ver. 3 VFC compatible internals.
CYMA's naming scheme is messed up.:mad:

I also have some general questions about the physical durability of guns. With NORMAL use (I don't bang my guns on trees and cars and such), has anybody run into any problems with molded ABS or pot metal externals? Also, has anybody had rust or corrosion problems on steel parts? (from what i understand, pot metal is a blend of cheap metals like tin, zinc, aluminum... etc. and chemically, they are nowhere near as susceptible to corrosion as steel, and don't "rust".

If there is another nice clone gun that would work as a good beginner platform, please don't hesitate to suggest it. One condition though, no M4/M16 or any AR type guns, I don't like that family of guns to begin with, and I see WAY too many of them.

Thank you so much, any help is greatly appreciated. :D
Sincerely, an airsoft noob.

Cyma's numbering scheme has always been in standard numerical order. The 47C should be the one with the steel receiver.

You are correct that the CYMA 040 uses the VFC/LCT mounting system while the 047 uses the TM system for the front end. Not sure about the steel/monkey metal thing though.

Also have you seen a cool rusted steel AK? They look SICK, does this not make you want to get a cool weathered AK (not sure if that's Real Steel or airsoft, I found them on my computer and don't remember the context of how I got those)?

http://i.imgur.com/vwXJz.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/BPVYJ.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/VOc1G.jpg

As for other beginner guns may I suggest the JG or CYMA MP5, or the Echo1 P90.

I personally dont like the look of weathered guns, im one of those idiots who like to maintain their guns to look like mint condition (chipped paint and silver scratches already irritate me, let alone rust lol), even something that is supposed to look rugged like an AK.

those look pretty bad ass, looks like it's gone through a hundred
I like the used look too but I rather it naturally look worn then cosmetically worn down

All are good guns but with shipping brokage and what not, you're adding 140$. Just buy canadian. A VA36 (which is just a re branded jg) would be you best bet.


You can get the cm AKs from airsoftdepot. They sell a lot of cyma stuff.

Jerry thanks for the advice, but i am buying this as a part of a much larger order with other people, we worked out the brokerage fees and duties and everything and in the end we're still saving quite a bit. plus, now that the law's changed all the items are perfectly legal and should pass customs.

Just beware that you know what you're getting into.... But if you've done the math and it's right and you save a chunk of change that's worth it to you then go for it. (ie. I'll probably buy Canadian for an extra $20 or so because it's in country and I can get it "now" in 4-7 days whereas from overseas I'd have to wait like 3 weeks or whatever their delivery standard times are).

I doubt you can keep your guns looking like new once you start gaming it.

The more you use it, the more wear and scratches it will receive. After you gamed a dozen games, please report back your new looking gun.

thanks, but back to the question at hand, the main thing i wanna know is whether molded ABS plastic or pot metal bodies (versus fibre reinforced plastics or full steel) are problematic in the long run in terms of durability. oh and i forgot to mention that i will be mainly playing woodland games. like does anybody have any issues with china clones breaking on them (externally) or anything like that?

Another thing i wanted to know is, which gun's iron sight is better (big fan of iron sights lol), the AK's rear notch and front post, or the G36's flip-up rear peep sight and hooded front post?

Right now, I'm kind of leaning towards the JG G36K, and then getting a KSK-style CNC alum carry handle/rail, and mounting HK416 iron sights on it. but i would like to hear all sides of the story and can still be easily swayed, as i am really torn between these two guns. knowing is half the battle, right? :D

If you've done the math and you guys are going to save a bunch then by all means go for it. Just remember that just because you're within your legal rights doesn't mean the government is aware of it. Not all CBSA agents are fully aware of all importation laws. Guns and other items (airsoft and not) that are legal for import still get seized and sent for testing. This could mean you won't receive your gun for several months, this is a real possibility and however large or small you should be aware of and willing to accept the potential risk.

I personally like to support Canadian businesses whenever possible, if the difference is "small" I'd rather support my local airsoft store. It helps them grow keeps my money in Canada and doesn't promote excessive shipping distances etc etc end of lecture.

As far as a choice between the guns you've mentioned. I say go AK but I'm bias and don't care much for the G36. Both have a v3 mechbox but the AK has the advantage of a motor cage. The G36 probably has a better hop-up design, easier to adjust IMO. AK mags are taller but don't have the awkward tabs on them which make G36 mags more difficult to maneuver in and out of pouches. AK gear and accessories are more abundant. Other than that it's really up to personal preference of ergonomics and aesthetics.

CYMA AK's have a good reputation for being a great gun for the price and should last you a while. Not sure the difference between the different models but I'd go with the VFC style it's more realistic.

Sights are really a matter of preference. The G36 iorns are more spread out across the gun, one could argue that they're more accurate. But the AK sights are closer to the front making them better for quick acquisition.

Bottom line is that generally speaking although they're lighter plastic bodies are weaker then metal ones, especially in the cold when plastic can become brittle. Rarely does anyone ever break their gun on purpose but guns break. No one can tell you where, when or if you'll break your gun.

Ironsights are something you'll need to experience first hand. AK iron sights come naturally to me, everything lines right up instantly and I can acquire a target much faster than with an AR style peep sight. But the HK sights you mentioned I find equally effective, at least when I rotate the drum to open topped position.

Oh kozzie, you have no idea, it was a hard decision for me choose to buy abroad and have it shipped, the other guys im buying with are all either cash-strapped and need the extra bit of savings, or need a specific gun that nobody (and i do mean nobody) in Canada carries new, or both (like me). We are all very well briefed on the current situation of airsoft law and are willing to take the risks to get what we want.

you said the g36 gearbox doesnt have a motor cage, this is a pic of the gearbox:http://i942.photobucket.com/albums/a...0204001700.jpg
theres like a metal arm thats holding the motor in place, but obviously nothing compared to the full cage of the cyma ver 3 ak, do you think that's going to cause any problems? and is having a cage really significant?

sorry for all the questions, still an inexperienced noob lol

Yes sir, will do! XD

oh and disco dante, man you should hear me rave about H&K's drum and hooded front post sights, personally i think they are the best thing that ever happened to iron sights. I was kinda disappointed when the G36 didn't come standard with them, but that's just me and im kinda crazy lol.

Shirley you don't HAVE to buy with all those guys. If you want to order from out of country or not it's your decision right?

Basically what I was getting at is the main differences between the two are aesthetics and ergonomics. Neither is definitively leaps and bounds better than the other. You need to chose which one best suits you. I'm assuming you've found some reviews on them and neither of them are inherently shitty? If so neither will be a bad purchase.

They both have very similar mag releases but the selector switches are quite different, which do you prefer?

G36 has a fixed pistol grip, the AK grip can be changed to suit your preference.

The G36 can be converted to take STANAG mags the AK not so much.

Is one heavier than the other? do you like that?

Have you considered batteries? does one hold a larger battery allowing you to play longer without switching?

Which one is best suited to the gear you plan to get/have?

Why don't you just go into your local airsoft store or to a game and see them in person Shoulder them both see which one feels best to you? That should help you decide even if it's not the exact models you're looking at. Or maybe go to GI and see them before you buy. ;)

to answer your questions, the AK is both heavier and longer (by about 8-10 cm if i remember correctly), now im a pretty tall guy so either is okay. dont really care for stanag mags, in terms of battery the AK uses a stick type housed under the receiver cover and gas tube, while the G36 uses a mini type under the barrel hidden inside the handguard.
The gun doesn't really affect my other gear/kit as i'm not going for any particular theme, and plan on having assault rifle mag pouches on a load bearing vest or a plate carrier, and having a dump pouch on my belt.

and yes, i have already gone to the Toronto Airsoft store a couple times and plan to go again in the next two weeks, will definitely take that opportunity to try out both styles of guns if they have them.

I would save and buy both. Someones gun always goes down at a game and a back up is always usefull. Plus more airsoft guns = more fun!

unfortunately i am already buying a sniper rifle on top of my assault rifle, kinda breakin the bank here for a university student who just paid for books and tuition XD.

any more advice or suggestions?

Sniper rifles cost a fortune to upgrade and they are not as fun as you think. I've been at this since May I believe and picked up so far;
Ares M4 AEG
VFC Scar-H AEG
VFC G36KV GBBR
Javelin M24 Bolt
KWA MK23 GBBP
KWA USP Tact GBBP

Cost me a fortune but I'll tell you the sniper rifle is the least useful but luckily I didn't pay much for it. Sniper rifles are hella expensive to upgrade and will require you to carry a side arm unless you want to carry your full size AEG rifle as that....
The extra money is better used to buy extra mags, batteries, a smarter charger and upgrades you may want.

the sniper i am getting is already pre-upgraded, i dont plan on having to up the power any more, i just need to get a 40$ tightbore for it and i should be good up to about 250 to 300 ft, as for a sniper sidearm, i really havent thought about getting one yet, if i do, itll probably be a gbb mk23 or a MP7, but at this point if i'm rolling sniper, i will have the assault rifle on my back, and i'll ditch my usual leg-holster and pistol setup.

300 feet is pretty good.

hey guys, need your help again, I have been led by some to believe that the JG MK36K has a plastic hopup chamber, can somebody confirm or disprove this? or do the old ones have a plastic hopup and the new ones have metal?
i know the cyma AK has a metal hopup chamber for sure

another nooby question, but how much does the material of the hopup chamber matter in terms of reliability? I have seen a few cracked or ruptured hopup chambers, but most seems to be due to abuse rather than design. (or i could be very, very wrong lol)
I like the G36 and AK in real life because of their bulletproof reliability, and that's not about to change in airsoft :)